IIS App Pools - Stop/Start vs Recycle

IIS App Pools - Stop/Start vs Recycle

I've noticed that on one of my production web apps, when I manually recycle an app pool, the recycled worker process can take upwards of 60+ seconds to actually be completely destroyed, based on watching it in Task Manager. However, if I stop the app pool completely, the worker process goes away nearly instantaneously - within 1-2 seconds.

So, my question is two-fold:

a) Why does it take so long to destroy the process (and more meaningfully, release the resources used/locked by it) when the app pool is recycled instead of stopped; and

b) Assuming that I've stopped traffic from being directed to the server, is there any reason NOT to stop/start instead of recycle?

Edit: To clarify, before I either recycle or stop the app pool, I stop traffic from being sent to the server in question (the server is in a load balanced cluster, and I remove the server from the load balancer). So, in theory, there should be no requests coming to the web site at the time I am doing anything to the app pool.

Edit Part Deux: After reading Igal's link, it seems pretty obvious to me what is happening. When I recycle the app pool, the new process is started, but since there is no traffic at all, it isn't registering the new process as functioning, so it doesn't shut down the old one until the timeout (which is 90 seconds).

With that knowledge, it's clear to me that the "Recycle" functionality is specifically intended to be used midstream on a live server, and since I am manually draining traffic beforehand, I should use stop/start instead.

Access sites on IIS


GC Not Running Often Enough on IIS 7 Application - Windows Server 2008
a) Because of Overlapped Recycling.

301 redirects with Joomla on IIS
There is a time period that the "old" process waits for the new one to start..
IIS Keep-Alive between web and app server
b) No.

Downloading MDB (Access) file from IIS
As far as I know..
GZIP without using IIS?

IIS Architecture: What signals w3wp.exe to start?

Force download of a file on a network share through IIS


A recycle if I recall correctly allows all existing requests to finish then it will recycle the application pool.

A stop simply ends it at the exact instant that you stop it..

76 out of 100 based on 86 user ratings 1036 reviews